hotels

Florida Keys Rental Houses

5 min read
Florida Keys Rental Houses

Dreaming of the Florida Keys? Discover the best rental houses, from Key West conch houses to Islamorada waterfront estates. Your guide to finding the perfect island home for your tropical getaway.

The Florida Keys are a 125-mile string of tropical islands, each with its own unique personality, stretching off the southern tip of Florida. While hotels and resorts are plentiful, the true way to experience the “Conch Republic” is by staying in a Florida Keys rental house. It offers the space, privacy, and authentic island living that hotels simply can’t match.

Whether you’re dreaming of a historic Key West conch house or a modern Islamorada waterfront estate with a private dock, this guide will help you find the perfect home for your unforgettable Keys vacation.

Top Florida Keys Rental Houses by Location

The Keys are divided into several main regions, each offering a different vibe. Here are the top types of rental houses you can find.

1. Key West: Historic Conch Houses & Vibrant Cottages

The Vibe: Lively, historic, and walkable. Perfect for those who want to be in the heart of the action near Duval Street, yet have a private retreat to return to.

  • Classic Conch House: These historic homes, often built from native limestone, are full of charm. Think wooden shutters, wide porches (wraparound verandas), and lush, private courtyards.

  • Hidden Garden Cottage: Tucked away behind a main house, these cozy rentals offer surprising seclusion just blocks from the bustling streets. They are often more budget-friendly while providing an authentic Key West feel.

  • Luxury Waterfront Compound: For the ultimate splurge, rent a multi-bedroom estate on the canal or with ocean access. Features often include a private pool, a dock for your boat, and stunning sunset views.

2. Islamorada: Sportfishing & Waterfront Family Estates

The Vibe: The “Sportfishing Capital of the World.” Ideal for families and anglers seeking direct water access and a more relaxed, residential feel.

  • The Angler’s Dream Home: These houses are designed for fishing trips. They feature deep-water docks, fish cleaning stations, and boat lifts. Many are on canals leading straight to the Atlantic or Gulf.

  • Spacious Family Retreat: With multiple bedrooms, large living areas, and private pools, these homes are perfect for family reunions or groups of friends. You’ll find modern kitchens and open-plan layouts for easy entertaining.

3. Marathon: Central Location & Kid-Friendly Homes

The Vibe: Family-oriented and centrally located. Home to the world-famous Sombrero Beach and the Dolphin Research Center.

  • Beachside Bungalow: Secure a rare find—a house just a short walk or bike ride from a sandy beach like Sombrero Beach. These are highly sought-after for their convenience.

  • Canal Home with Pool: Many rentals in Marathon offer the best of both worlds: a boat dock on a canal for daily adventures and a private freshwater pool for cooling off in the afternoon.

4. Duck Key & Hawk’s Cay: Resort-Style Luxury Villas

The Vibe: Upscale, manicured, and resort-like. These communities offer a curated experience with high-end amenities.

  • Hawk’s Cay Villa: These condos and villas provide access to the resort’s incredible amenities, including multiple pools, a dolphin lagoon, a marina, and several restaurants, while giving you the space of a private rental.

  • Duck Key Waterfront Home: Rent a luxurious house within a private community, often with a private pool, a dock, and access to shared amenities like tennis courts and marina facilities.

5. Lower Keys & Big Pine Key: Secluded Nature Lovers’ Escape

The Vibe: Quiet, rustic, and natural. This is the place to disconnect and enjoy the wild side of the Keys, famous for the National Key Deer Refuge.

  • Off-the-Grid Stilt House: Experience true seclusion with a house built on stilts among the mangroves. These are perfect for kayakers, bird watchers, and those seeking absolute peace.

  • Cozy Key Deer Cottage: Charming, often more affordable cottages on larger pieces of land where you’re likely to be visited by the adorable, dog-sized Key deer.

What to Look for in Your Florida Keys Rental House

To ensure your island home meets all your needs, keep an eye out for these key features:

  • Water Access: This is the #1 priority for many.

    • Canal Front: Great if you’re renting a boat.

    • Oceanfront/Bayfront: For direct swimming, kayaking, and sublime water views.

    • Beach Access: A true luxury in the Keys, as natural sandy beaches are rare.

  • Private Pool: A near-essential feature for most travellers. The perfect place to cool off after a day in the sun.

  • Dock & Boat Lift: If you’re an angler or plan to explore by water, a dock with a boat lift is a game-changer.

  • Outdoor Living Space: Look for properties with a spacious deck, lanai, patio, and an outdoor shower. You’ll spend most of your time outside.

  • Key West Style Architecture: For an authentic feel, seek out homes with classic features like metal roofs, wooden shutters, and gingerbread trim.

Pro Tips for Booking Your Keys Rental

  1. Book Early: The best Florida Keys rental houses get snatched up fast, especially for peak season (December-April). Aim to book 6-12 months in advance.

  2. Read the Fine Print: Pay close attention to cleaning fees, security deposits, and cancellation policies. Some properties have minimum stays (e.g., 7 nights).

  3. Consider Your Location: Do you want to be walking distance to restaurants and bars (Key West), or are you happy driving to amenities (Islamorada, Marathon)?

  4. Check for Amenities: Confirm that essential amenities like Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a fully-equipped kitchen are included.

  5. Use a Reputable Platform: Book through well-known vacation rental sites or established local property management companies in the Keys for security and peace of mind.

You may also like